Acorns and Alibis: On the Misuse of Newman's Development
Newman wrote An Essay on the Development of Christian Doctrine in 1845 while his Anglicanism was collapsing under him, and he stopped writing it midstream to be received into the Roman church by Domenico Barberi that October. That timing is not coincidental. The book was not a disinterested inquiry that happened to lead him to Rome; it was the argument he needed to make the move intellectually survivable. By 1845 he had already abandoned the Via Media , already watched Tract 90 fail to read the Thirty-Nine Articles in a catholic sense, already convinced himself that Anglicans stood roughly where the Semi-Arians or Monophysites had stood in the early councils, with Rome as the catholic party. His line from the Essay's introduction is famous and still gets quoted at me in comment threads: to be deep in history is to cease to be Protestant. The trouble is that the history did not actually deliver what he wanted, and he knew it, which is why he had to supply a theory that would let hi...